71 Comments
User's avatar
Dr. Sarah's avatar

Also, maybe we can ask the county to apply their HHS PAUSE acronym to the comp plan?

Jeff Tozzer's avatar

That would make a terrific public comment! Please consider it for October 13th.

Jeff Tozzer's avatar

Sent today:

Commissioners and Director Emery,

Tuesday’s hearing made the risk plain. Futurewise’s attorney told you the Climate Vulnerability Assessment is only “one step,” cited the Thurston County ruling that soft planning language is not enough, and previewed an appeal if Clallam does not lock in action-forcing policies. The draft you are moving already supplies that record: extreme scenarios treated as fact, “shall” language waiting in the wings, and a county admission that staff exceeded what House Bill 1181 requires.

HB 1181 requires a climate resilience section. It does not require a Climate Vulnerability Assessment, greenhouse-gas reduction policies, or the hottest forecast in the set. The draft Climate Element says Clallam is not required to address the greenhouse-gas section, then notes that staff exceeded the minimum. That is a choice, and it is the choice Futurewise will use.

Please do three things before this plan is finalized:

1. Do not adopt the Climate Element or the CVA as written. Rewrite the assessment around middle-range projections, with uncertainties stated in plain language. Stop treating RCP 8.5 and the high end of the 2012 MACA downscaling as the county’s working forecast. The observed record in the same document is about 1.4°F since 1895. A 9°F end-of-century summer figure is a scenario, not a fact the code should enforce for 20 years.

2. Meet HB 1181 and stop there. Keep “promote,” “encourage,” and “explore.” Do not convert them to “shall,” timelines, named departments, or measurable targets that turn a resilience chapter into a permit manual. Reject the Marine Resources Committee request to make climate forecasts binding and to put a biologist on critical-areas and shoreline files as a climate condition.

3. Fix the conflict before the vote. Page 14 cites the North Olympic Development Council for the claim that this warming “will bring significant consequences.” Commissioner Ozias sits on that board. He should recuse himself from any vote that adopts NODC work product as the scientific basis for restrictions on private property. The same standard should apply to everyone: tribal trust land is already outside county critical-areas code; do not write a climate chapter that regulates fee-simple owners more strictly than the trust parcels next door.

Futurewise wins most of its appeals because counties write the record for them. Do not do that here. The people who own the land did not ask you to exceed the statute.

Denise Lapio's avatar

Fantastic, Jeff! I started reading the Comp Plan and noticed a mix of shall and should in the same sentence repeatedly. It's like Emery is putting in every request and hoping no one complains just to get it passed.

Laurie Roening's avatar

There are a lot of frustration with the county it's finally clear cc Watchdog research has opened a lot of our eyes and ears. thank you

Jeff Tozzer's avatar

You're always welcome :)

Kristin's avatar

Laurie

Exactly then after read comments to get even more information. Great way to get locally smart.

Michael Heath's avatar

We are sick and tired of those in the county treating us as if we have no property rights or freedoms to live here in peace! The outrageous taxes, lies about "voter approved fees" that we NEVER voted for or approved, the shady, closed-door meetings and special deals between NGOs and foreign governments, and this constant fake science BS about the world coming to an end that has NEVER been accurate for the past 50+ years! We will NOT tolerate any more unconstitutional big government oppression and attacks upon our freedom and rights!

Sincerely, Mike

Timothy Weller's avatar

"NO KINGS", as their actions to the contrary are clearly king-worthy. The "models and projections" hopefully incorporate data pertaining to seismic activity at our frront door. That, my friends, is climate change, that requires all new buildings to be seismically engineered, especially fuel stations, green leafy substance dispensaries, fire station, hotels and casinos built on flood plains, in a tsunami zone, correct? The most extraordinary aspect of all this fluff, is that it has advanced to the current point we find ourselves at, and continues on. It is an absurd assumption that the earth is static; we are one good shaker away from being Olympic Island (and we thought our R.E. Taxes were bad, now), and a lesson in what actually establishes "land use." But if we throw enough of someone else's money and resources at these engineered crises...

Michael Heath's avatar

Great comment, Patriot Timothy Weller~!

It is very clear that these communists instantly attack anyone who is not in favor of THEIR dictator "kings and queens", so of course they blame those good folks for being "kings and queens" themselves, in their mentally deranged way to confuse folks. Yes, these communists know that the American Patriots are NOT interested in being mini dictators, but their "useful idiots" are obviously clueless and as ignorant as they come. Oh yes, these communists stealing tax dollars and everything else that they can get their filthy claws on, to weaponize everything possible against America and the good Americans, is definitely their "go to" method of destruction. The more President Trump and his administration clamps down on the communist's evil corruption machine, the more they panic and become even more obviously criminally corrupt. That is how "we" know that we are right over the target and destroying the communist's evil playground~! Every day that goes by, these communists lose their sick cover stories of being "Progressives" and "socialists", to reveal their true evil intentions!!! Much of their money laundering and financial fraud has been removed, so they are running out of money to steal... Hang in there my friend~!

Sincerely, Mike

Dr. Sarah's avatar

At timestamp 1:12:20 for this podcast, there's noticeable typing audible on the recording. I recall hearing this during the Zoom session (sorry, I don't have the meeting timestamp) and looking at the dais to see who was distracted during such a passionate public comment, but the video resolution made it difficult to make out details. Did anyone else catch that?

Jeff Tozzer's avatar

It's me! I was typing last night while playing the public comments. Nothing important, just writing my speech for the Pulitzer committee.

Vanessa Baker's avatar

Excellent work!! Again. 💪🏻 Thank you.

jedjennings50's avatar

The climate agenda is a hoax? More control, another disaster, fear mongering, and facts that are manipulated. Wow we have a solution that makes no sense and only creates chaos with us property owners. These commissioners hire people to do their jobs that already have an agenda and then try to convince us we need to react. CC is fine if these people would just go away and stay away. Let CC run our county and the hell with the Olympia and liberal power grabbers!

Sheldon McGuire's avatar

Clallam County Comp Plan. 2026.

“I am from the government and I am here to help.” I believe this was a quotation from then President Ronald Regan. Regardless, there is truth in this saying. The opposite is reality.

A Comp Plan is not a brochure. It is the 20-year instruction book for Critical Areas, shoreline rules, housing, wells, rentals, and what “climate risk” means when you want to pull a permit. Extreme assumptions in, extreme code out. Futurewise does not need to invent a record. Harvey, Cascadia, and CCA dollars already typed it.

Warning. This is “your government” at work. Read the small print. Find the intentional invasion of each individual’s living standards, the way to own property, to minimize tax burdens, to survive. Too many rules.

Who prospers with these rules? We voters in Clallam County have a power-hungry set of elected officials. This governance is self-serving, invasive, and frightening. Less is best. The constant, aggressive nature of our elected officers is not in the best interests of the citizens of Clallam County. Sadly, the majority of our citizens do not read these documents. The result is often a nasty surprise when new rules, new standards, become new restrictions on our way of life.

When the red flag is showing we voters need to respond. Doing nothing allows for a disappointment when these “new” rules become law.

CC Watchdog has reported Cascadia’s use of ICLEI tools. ICLEI is the German-based network that sells local governments software, methods, and a global “movement” vocabulary. The NODC — the nonprofit Commissioner Ozias has led — recruited local governments toward ICLEI membership and even offered to help pay dues. NODC and the Tribe have been ICLEI members. That is not a planning department finding science in a file cabinet. That is a consultant-nonprofit-tribal circuit writing the assumptions, then sending them to the dais for the vote. This move toward globalization is frightening. I am still asking the question, who gains from all these new regulations, mandates, and laws?

Hello! I am speaking to you, our Clallam County voters, home owners, business owners. Wake up!

The voice of the individual is being suppressed and lost. Organizations across the world are becoming more forceful and invasive. This is international, and intentional. Again, read the small print.

Action. Action is needed. We voters must start to realize that our elected officials are not working to make our life better, but are giving away many of our long-fought-for rights. Speak up. Vote for change. Protect our local citizenry and our historical way of living. The red flags are flying.

CAS's avatar

Thank you, well said! And exacly right about the majority of our citizens do not read documents or educate themselves on what is going on in this county. Even this little county is getting wrapped up in all the "global movement". We have to change the direction, starting with this November, vote Jake. And next year and the following year with replacements for our current commissioners. If not, we see the writing on the wall....we are already circling the drain.

Sheldon McGuire's avatar

CAS. Thanks. It is sad that our education system is failing as well. My call to action is all I know how to alert all of us we are under attack. The more we learn about globalization the more concerned I become. The best defense is to vote. Clear the decks and put in a group of officials dedicated to improving Clallam County.

KK's avatar

Agreed, CAS!

Jennifer's avatar

COME ON, GIVE THEM A BREAK, THEY ARE ALL JUST DOING THEIR JOBS!

SNOW JOBS: blind the reader with a blizzard of facts so that he hardly notices the fiction.

Snow Job: stems from the metaphoric image of being snowed under, but with words specifically. The term snow job refers to the act of persuading or deceiving someone by overwhelming them with information.

CAS's avatar

I am just focusing on one aspect of this. Residents of the Olympic Peninsula understand one simple truth: we drive because we have to. Geography, distance, and rural realities shape our daily lives. Yet HB 1181 imposes statewide vehicle miles traveled (VMT) reduction mandates that ignore the lived experience of rural communities like ours. This bill may not ban driving outright, but it attempts to reshape how we live, where we live, and how we move — without acknowledging that our region cannot be retrofitted into an urban model. There are those who want complete control of us.

HB 1181 requires cities and counties to adopt land use and transportation strategies designed to reduce per capita VMT. These strategies include infill housing, mixed use zoning, transit oriented development, expanded sidewalk networks, bike lanes, and frequent transit service. These may be appropriate for dense metropolitan areas, but they are fundamentally mismatched to the realities of the Peninsula. We do not live in Seattle, Bellevue, or Tacoma. We live in a region where essential services, jobs, medical care, and groceries are miles apart. Driving is not a luxury — it is a necessity.

The concern is not simply about transportation. It is about control, overreach, and the growing expectation that citizens must quietly accept sweeping policy changes justified by fear based messaging. For decades, climate narratives have shifted — from global cooling, to global warming, to the broad and vague term “climate change.” The message has remained the same: be afraid, comply, and don’t question the motives. Meanwhile, some of the loudest voices in climate advocacy have profited enormously. It is reasonable — and responsible — to ask who benefits financially from these mandates and whether rural communities are being asked to sacrifice autonomy for policies that do not fit our circumstances.

HB 1181’s VMT requirements will not meaningfully reduce emissions in rural counties. Instead, they will burden local governments, restrict housing choices, and pressure communities to adopt land use patterns that undermine the character and practicality of rural life. The Peninsula cannot be made walkable by legislative decree. We cannot bike our way to medical appointments in Port Angeles. We cannot rely on transit systems that do not exist.

Policy should be grounded in reality, not ideology. Rural communities deserve solutions tailored to their needs — not one size fits all mandates crafted for urban centers. HB 1181’s VMT reduction requirements fail that test. They impose expectations that are neither feasible nor fair for the people who live, work, and drive on the Peninsula. Remember this all about power and control and the taking of land here on the peninsula, through whatever means. And indeed this “plan” is being rushed on purpose. Don’t forget who benefits in this county from this outrageous plan.

HB 1181 legally binds many Washington jurisdictions to include VMT reduction in their climate plans, provides model guidance, and mandates reporting to track progress, making it a significant driver of long-term transportation and land use changes aimed at lowering vehicle miles driven. What next, will they find a way to take our vehicles from us ?

KK's avatar

Thank You CCWD for such great information shared! Great selection of Public Commenters!

It is very maddening what is happening.

The bottom line, is they want the entire county with no one living here, or you are locked down under high laws/regulations, where you can't actually live a free life. It would be a lifestyle of a prison.

UFOCCWD's avatar

These climate issues are designed to escalate and create jobs through NGO's for radical run activist to hopefully control counties because counties have mass multi millions of tax $$$ to play with because the people are over taxed.The amount of NGO's, committees,groups,stewardships ect ect ect that are tied to environmental issues is mind boggling.All these high paying activist want to do is sit around and B.S. to create new fees,raise old ones,create new penalties for new laws attack attack attack the public for more $$$ 'Radical Ripoffs'.

Larry Mason's avatar

Would it be possible to ask county commissioners to have county climate projections reviewed by someone such as Dr. Cliff Mass, UW atmospheric scientist and PNW weather expert, who has been critical in the past of extreme climate projections?

https://environment.uw.edu/faculty/clifford-mass/

NorTexWarrior's avatar

Please attend a BOCC meeting or two or three and speak on this. Send your letters. And invite Cliff Mass!

Lawrence Martin's avatar

Lets make everything a crisis. Carbon is not a pollutant. It is a natural element. Ice cores prove carbon fluctuations. Increased carbon isn't a bad thing. Less reliance on fertilizers. Crop.yields are up. The Sahara is shrinking. In the meantime, something way out of mans control like Krakatoa has come alive throwing carbon, ash, sulphur and silica into the atmosphere at 50,000 feet. Large sea mounts form all over the Pacific oceans Ring of Fire.

Cliff Mass from UW says manmade climate change is overblown. He states in another 30 years as the power grid is transformed and energy is produced at 21st century scale combining modern nuclear power you can offset excessive carbon with carbon capture and scrubbing.

Dale Russell's avatar

"Harsh climate scenarios have spent decades painting Earth's likely future landscape as dystopian, dark, barren and forbidding.

Yet, recent physical data argues exactly the opposite. Instead of plunging the planet into chaos, it's becoming eye-catchingly greener - and CO₂ is the key. The formal models predicted a scorched planet, but NASA satellites unleashed a world that is biologically thriving. This silent miracle of global greening isn't some theory, it's the physical reality captured by the orbiting space platforms; MODIS instruments on NASA's Terra and Aqua satellites.

This is how these jarring narratives have been unfolding:

* Official Climate Narrative: Rapid, systemic desertification and global canopy loss due to rising temperatures.

* Hard Reality: Persistent structural greening across more than 30% of the global vegetated area over the last two decades.

* Official Climate Narrative: CO₂ acts strictly as a destructive atmospheric pollutant driving extreme weather.

* Hard Reality: CO₂ is plant food, driving down stomatal conductance, making plants use water more efficiently and expanding the leaf area index.

* Official Climate Narrative: Global food supply chains are on the verge of climate-driven collapse.

* Hard Reality: Agricultural yields bolstered by CO₂ fertilisation are expanding green cover in semi-arid zones like the African Sahel and Western Australia."

https://x.com/PeterDClack/status/2058863998993604922

4 reasonable development's avatar

Reminds me of Towne Road and what a fight that was to keep our county roads. People showed up week after week, letter after letter to keep control over a county road. That whole area out in Dungeness would have been controlled by the tribe. The area would have been shut off, signs posted like they have on their properties, “no trespass” “tribal land use only”. There were no trespass signs put up and locked gates placed by the county, hoping they would remain permanent is my guess? if it were not for loud local opposition occurring because all the guns were called in even from the Seattle area. Don’t forget OUR county leaders were in on it, they were willing and ready to hand it over just like what is going on with Protection Island and the Dungeness Spit! How cozy the arrangement is that our county leaders are working for the tribe instead of their taxpayers! NO MORE, NO MAS! Just wanted to remind everyone about how our county leaders aren’t working for you but against you and all the tax dollars paying for it!

Three Crabs is all part of the plan to take over more county property, for what? For a tribe that consists of a few hundred people that are not getting stipends to help them exist? For a tribe that makes millions every year and does not share with their own people? For a tribe that are American USA citizens like everyone else and benefits little from their own tribe. Ask yourself WHY?

Jennifer's avatar

JAMESTOWN COMPREHENSIVE PLAN SINCE 1985 AND REVISED IN 1916. It has been planned for 21 years to take back the peninsula. They seem to be right on track.

https://jamestowntribe.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/Comprehensive_Plan_Revised_in_2016_Final.pdf

READ PAGE 13 ON LAND CONSOLIDATION AND REFER TO MAP ON PAGE 14

History of Indian Land Consolidation

Over the last century the Indian Land Consolidation Act, the Land Buy Back Program, and other Federal programs have attempted to solve the problem of fractionation.

Congress enacted the Indian Land Consolidation Act in 1983. The act sought to reduce fractionation by prohibiting small land interests from passing to heirs upon an individual Indian landowner’s death. Instead, small land interests would revert or “escheat” to Tribal ownership. (Sneak in the Three Crabs, eh?)

https://www.bia.gov/bia/history/history-indian-land-consolidation

Kristin's avatar

and let's not forget the 30 million lawsuit CC just lost:

"PORT ORCHARD — A $30 million verdict against Clallam County has been awarded to a former Sheriff’s Office deputy who lost part of his leg.

A Kitsap County jury on Thursday awarded a gross verdict of $30,176,905 to former Deputy Matthew Murphy and his wife, Margaret Conway, according to a news release.

Murphy was injured during a training exercise with the Sheriff’s Office in an incident that caused him to lose his right leg below the knee, according to the release.

“The jury found Clallam County negligent and its negligence a proximate cause of his injuries, assigning the county 95 percent of the fault and Murphy 5 percent of the fault,” the release stated.

Clallam County officials were not available for comment Monday morning.

The injury occurred during a training exercise on March 27, 2020, when Murphy was completing mandatory rifle qualification and his AR-15 discharged during a support-side shoulder transition, shooting him in the top of his right foot, according to the release. Murphy underwent 10 surgical procedures over four years before a below-the-knee amputation in 2024.

“Some of deputy Murphy’s co-workers testified that he was ridiculed and humiliated for shooting himself by other deputies at the Clallam County Sheriff’s Office,” the release stated.

During the trial, Murphy and his wife argued that Clallam County’s training instructions and equipment choices created a foreseeable entanglement hazard: “a three-point rifle sling caught on Murphy’s over-the-head hearing protection as he performed the required maneuver,” the release stated. “The county disputed responsibility and argued that Murphy was at fault.”

The award in Murphy’s favor includes $20 million for his pain, disability and other noneconomic losses, $5 million for his wife’s loss of consortium, and $5,176,905 in past and future economic damages. The $30.1 million figure is the jury’s gross award before any court-ordered adjustments, according to the release.

“Matt’s injury never should have happened had Clallam County followed its own safety policies,” Davis Law Group founder Chris Davis said in the release. “The jurors looked beyond the moment the rifle discharged and considered the county’s lack of training and unsafe equipment decisions over a 24-year period that put him in that position. The county violated its own safety obligation to stay current with best practices in the area of firearms training and related equipment.”

Note this part: ------------------------------------------- CC at it's best :(

Murphy filed the lawsuit against the county in 2023, according to the release. The parties participated in a full-day mediation in October 2024, but the county refused to offer any money to settle the case.

During the trial, Murphy offered to settle the case for $10 million, but the county ignored the offer, according to the release.