37 Comments
User's avatar
Dr. Sarah's avatar

Great reporting, @JeffTozzer. While everyone is understandably focused on the General Manager’s 28.8% climb to nearly $300k, ratepayers should also look at the compensation package collected by the three commissioners who just waved that raise through with zero public discussion.

Under Washington law (RCW 54.12.080), PUD commissioners are supposed to be part-time citizen oversight—yet at Clallam PUD, each of the three commissioners pulls in:

-$3,238/month ($38,856/year) in automatic statutory base salary—indexed to inflation by the state, requiring zero local vote.

-$161/day in per diem for every official meeting, workshop, or conference they attend (capped at $22,540/year on top of base pay).

-Full public-sector benefits: Despite being part-time elected officials, commissioners are eligible to opt into full employee health, dental, and vision insurance packages, HRA-VEBA accounts, and state PERS retirement—all funded by the same ratepayers absorbing consecutive 3.75% electric, 4.75% water, and 9% wastewater hikes.

When you add base salary, per diems, and comprehensive medical/retirement benefits together, a "part-time" oversight seat easily clears $60,000 to $80,000+ in total taxpayer-funded value—right around or above the entire median household income in Clallam County ($70,370).

So when the Board meets at noon in Forks to rubber-stamp a $66,000 two-year raise using a closed-loop "peer average" that conveniently ignores what local families actually earn, it’s worth remembering: none of the four people in that room are feeling the pinch of a Clallam PUD utility bill.

At the December 14 meeting, ratepayers shouldn't just ask which eight utilities are in the GM's peer group—we should also ask for a full public accounting of total commissioner compensation, including every dollar claimed in per diems and district-paid health premiums over the last two years.

Joe Schmitt's avatar

I agree. We are not a California monster utility.

We are a tiny utility in an economic depressed county.

Depending on qualifications, maybe the manager position be let out for bids.

Who can have the same qualifications and do the job for less.

I bet you would get a ton of qualified bidders.

TLL's avatar

Good common sense call ,I was under the impression it was owned by we the people?

Annette Huenke's avatar

I always encourage people to talk about the pay packages, not just the salaries. Sean Worthington is making a lot more than $296k. When considering benefits packages in the administrative/managerial lane, the general rule of thumb is 40% of the salary. That puts the GM well over $400,000.

Consider yourselves fortunate — in June 2025, the JeffCo PUD commissioners anointed new GM Joe Wilson, crowning him with a whopping $365k salary. He came to be known as "Half-a-million Wilson," given he was costing the 21,400+- customer/owners over $500k. It appears he got the boot last month (details not yet released, to my knowledge) and you can bet his severance cost the ratepayers nearly another year's pay.

Peer comps are a clever scheme to up the inner circle ante for all the administrative/managerial class. Whether they find a new job or get fired from the old one, they laugh all the way to the bank.

Michael Heath's avatar

Awesome article here, Patriot Jeff Tozzer~!

Having an executive Personnel background going back to the days of "square wheels" it is my experience that the ONLY reasons for ANY Individual to be paid an extraordinarily grotesquely high salary (employment package) is either they have the actual ability to do a job that few if any others on earth can actually do (true unique expertise & talent), they are in a "criminally rigged Union environment" that has been perverted by "arm twisting, threats, and extortion" (corruption), OR the Individual is employed in a "dangerous and/or criminal" (illegal) job/activity that few if anyone of common sense and/or truly good character would be involved in~! As you have so well actually described here, the PUD system is more of a system of extortion with little to no real power allowed the general population, who are forced to accept the dictates of these real life ("king & queen") dictators who have an "iron hand" monopolistic stranglehold on public utilities and beyond. I also find it extremely revealing ("telling") that all of these COMPLETELY different categories of our absolutely critical infrastructure, and very existence, electricity, water, wastewater, and broadband (of all things!), are so "conveniently consolidated" under the COMPLETELY dominating authority of just one grotesquely overpaid Individual and his officially designated "co-conspirators" in this grand public milking machine, to which there are few if any options for anyone to escape their extortive "money pit" trap~! Yes, we are allowed to have our very limited say from time to time in this laughingly so-called "public utility" scam, but just as the other extortionists in the governmental system do, our wishes will be COMPLETELY ignored by decree~! I am not saying that "we" (the good folks of Clallam County) should give up, because that would clearly be the wrong thing to do because these power mad thugs need to be constantly reminded that we human beings actually exist, but I am saying that "we" do need to demand common sense changes and that good & honorable compassionate Individuals replace these greedy self-serving puppets who are basically "installed" into these positions that affect us all in our day to day lives. Lastly, I have to point out the humor, that ONLY in the criminally corrupt governmental matrix does the mix of electricity, water, sewage, and the Internet exist~! Don't try mixing all of those things at home~!!! HA~! May the future generations be merciful with their opinions about "our mental competence" today~!

Sincerely, Mike

Michael Heath's avatar

Happy Sunday, Patriot TLL~!

I hope that you are doing well and getting ready for a wonderful Thanksgiving Holiday FULL of Blessings~!

Sincerely, Mike

jedjennings50's avatar

Most raises in business are merit based. In this case I don’t see what he has done to deserve these pay raises. Give me some positive influence he has achieved to earn this monetary uptick. Otherwise it is thievery!

Michael Heath's avatar

"Positive influence"? HA! Not so much my friend~!

I believe that this "pay raise" is only the annual "reward" (AKA; "Bounty") for the tremendous Income increase (extortion) that clown boy presided over~! Much like a lying thieving salesman who produced nothing, but simply managed to increase profits on the exact same "product", this peckerwood is just being rewarded by the PUD grand milking machine that no one can ever really escape~! He is just a cold blooded paid "economic assassin"... Profit over people, is the communistic "economic model"~! This is NOT the common law American Republic free market economy that America was founded to have ;-)

Sincerely, Mike

Chris Clark's avatar

His raise alone is more than I make in a year on social security

This county is nothing but a money pit, every time you turn around we are getting stabbed.

Mac's avatar

More than both my wife and my yearly social security income!

William M. Cwirla's avatar

Obscene. That salary should be no more than half of what it is. It is an insult to every PUD customer in the county.

Denise Lapio's avatar

Another public figure earning an obscene salary and benefits package. A good article, Jeff, that makes me wonder who else is getting the same treatment. When people rightfully complain about the cost of food and utilities, I add onto their statement, and labor. It's the rising costs of labor and benefits that increase our bills because wages will always increase to help with the "cost of living" expenses. Another round-about. We, the average citizen, will, therefore, always be a dollar short.

CAS's avatar

Take a close look at your PUD bill, there is a "privlege tax", here is what I found researaching it:

The Washington State Public Utility District (PUD) Privilege Tax is 2.14%.

This tax is imposed on the "privilege" of operating works, plants, or facilities for the generation, distribution, and sale of electric energy within the state. It is designed to be a tax "in lieu of" property taxes, because PUDs are governmental entities and are generally exempt from paying property taxes.

The tax is calculated based on the PUD's gross revenue from the sale of electricity. On many customer bills, this is calculated after the State Public Utility Tax (which is 3.8734%) has already been applied to the charges.

The revenue collected from this tax is distributed as follows:

• A portion goes to the state general fund and public schools.

• The remainder is distributed proportionately to the counties that the PUD serves, allowing local schools and other taxing districts to receive revenue from the PUD.

CAS's avatar

Couldn't the state at least come up with a different name...seriously....."privlege"....smh

Denise Lapio's avatar

I really think it's an eerie implication. The name needs to be changed.

John Worthington's avatar

Another 3 minute clock watching body that has its marching orders from the 18 layer world governing system.

Dr. Sarah's avatar

Good Morning @JohnWorthington, any Relations to the PUD General Manager Sean Worthington?

John Worthington's avatar

Not that I know of.. but with a name like Worthington instead of Smith, we might be distant cousins from a few hundred years back.

m b's avatar

Purchased power obligations. Obligation to replace with green resources impossible to meet by a specific date or face increased cost. Times up.

jedjennings50's avatar

Jeff I wonder what the PUD director in PA earns? They are different municipalities. That would be a good comparison of salary.

Kathy's avatar

PUD wants to merge with the City of PA electric utility or take it over altogether. If they take it over completely there'll be a big payout, where's that money coming from? In either case how many more employees will they "need" and will one of them be another $296k general manager because one won't be able to handle it all?

Kristin's avatar

Also the City of PA has its own hinky going on with electric. Which is a whole seperate issue.

Kathy's avatar

Can you tell us what's going on there?

Garry Blankenship's avatar

Interesting that $ 66,000 two year raise is an enviable annual income for a lot of Clallam County citizens. So how will this cost increase among others be paid ? Raise the rates. What can they do about it ? A prime example of why our laws forbid monopolies. If anyone is dissatisfied with Clallam County PUD they can simply fire them and go to ??? As a practical matter the cost of installing an electrical grid is too expensive to allow for duplicity. However; when a public monopoly like CC PUD exists the "Board" that determines salaries must contain citizen customer representation who are paid meeting attendance stipends, not salaries. To be honest I do not know what the job responsibilities of the board commissioners are or what they are paid. A stipend system might be more fitting for them.

JJW's avatar

Please, bear with me, at my age I am going to ramble. I commented on this on these pages previously. Brother-in-law was an auditor in this state, this has been by now thirty or forty years ago. He mentioned that if the public knew how bad the PUDs were screwing the public they would be outraged. This appears to be the case now. Remember Nash the previous general manager. His package included 50 days off. I commented that if PUD could get by without him for that period of time someone else was capable of overseeing the operation. Apparently someone could. But at what cost. In addition, there were holidays, in addition to the 50 days. I wonder if the 50 days or a portion thereof were banked and paid lump some on his exit. Is the cost of living in one location the same in all county’s the same. Is this taken into consideration when hiring these people. Next. The county agreement with Astound for service in Joyce area.Apparently no survey was taken of potential market. It seems most have some satellite service. If Elon Musk is to be believed all that underground wire, would be for not. I would not bet against him. I could continue, but others have more informed opinions.

JJW's avatar

Remember Mr. Kelly and questions about pay and resident in Forks.

Dennis O's avatar

WOW!!! I think a major portion of the $66,000 increase was to cover the cost of all those "Elect Randy Brackett" campaign signs plastered all over Clallam County during the last election.

MK's avatar

You think you're hurting now, just wait for the Columbia River hydrolectric dams to come down so that Vancouver can flood again every spring. At least we'll get more red herring for the sea lions.

Jean Pratschner's avatar

I'm buying oil lamps, batteries, wool blankets, turning down or off the heat, and using the porch for refrigeration. Cant wait to see their fancy new digs when it is built. Maybe they could donate the old one in Sequim to a homeless shelter or classroom or municible building, or... new fire station so we dont have to build one in Carlsborg! Or all these.